My journey into the public realm of adoption discourse began with two life-changing interactions: I found and reunited with my birth mother during the time frame that I was getting to know my husband’s adult adopted son. I was in my thirties.
Reuniting with birth family meant I learned for the first time about the beginning of my life, that missing piece that had prevented my story from being whole. I heard my mother say she had not wanted to relinquish me, that she was given no other option. I heard her say she had not understood that the name she gave me would ever be changed. I wanted to understand what she’d gone through during her pregnancy and my birth, so I sought information about adoption in the late 1960s and I discovered Ann Fessler’s book The Girls Who Went Away. I learned that I was a product of a historical period in the U.S. called the Baby Scoop Era, so I sought information on what that meant. I wanted to understand how I had lost my original name, and I discovered that I’d had another birth certificate when I was born. For more than thirty years of my life, I had not known that I originally had a different birth certificate than the only one I’d ever seen.
Hearing my new stepson’s story meant I learned for the first time that my experience of being adopted was not an anomaly. I first heard his story from my husband’s point of view, so I heard that he had been adopted from Korea in the mid-1970s; that he was estimated to be four years old though his actual birth date was unknown; that he understood no English when he arrived in the U.S.; that he preferred sleeping on the floor rather than in a bed; that when he first saw a TV he inched over to it and held his fingers out to touch. This story was far different from the one I’d been told about myself.
But when I heard my stepson’s story in his own words, I recognized our commonality. My husband had left out the part about not fitting in. He’d left out the part about growing up as a Korean boy in an all-white neighborhood. My husband and my stepson attended the same grade school and high school, with a heavily Italian-American population. For my husband, this was a point of pride. But for my stepson, it had been torture. He was obviously different. There was no way he could blend in. He did not feel accepted, though he desperately wanted to be and tried to be. He had tried to become the son of his white parents, the brother of his white sister, the grandson of his white Mom-Mom and Pop-Pop. He had tried to become the Italian Catholic student, the suitable prom date.
I recognized when he spoke about his childhood that he never achieved what he tried to accomplish. He never was able to become a white boy. As an adult out in the world on his own, people saw him as Asian, or sometimes mistook him for Hispanic. They couldn’t tell by looking at him that he’d been raised white. Other Koreans tried to speak to him in their native language, but that tongue was long forgotten for him. He did not feel any more Korean than he did Italian. Just as I had felt all my life, he didn’t belong, only his not-belonging was amplified a thousand times by the fact that he was not only an adoptee, but an Asian adoptee navigating a Caucasian society without any guidance on how to do so.
Understand that this is my point of view about his point of view and that it is all I can offer, because he cannot share his story himself. At the age of 35, he ended his own life. Before he did so, there was much tumult. His death did not come out of the blue. He raged. He inflicted pain. He discarded people. He could be cruel.
He pleaded. He tried to give. He tried to love.
He mourned, though his mourning was unrecognized.
In my bones, I felt his anguish, because I knew also what it was to be adopted, to be taken from one place where you fit and placed into another where you never fit. Still, I felt inadequate to help. I was yet another person who failed him, in a long line of people who had failed him.
I don’t mean to imply that adoption was the only significant factor in my stepson’s ending his life. I absolutely do mean to implicate adoption in his suicide.
It is because of knowing my stepson, along with learning my beginning story, that I became empowered to begin writing about my own experience, and then sharing what I wrote, and then speaking my truth aloud. I wanted to say to others what I had not been able to say to my stepson, what I had not yet been aware of, what I had been afraid to voice. I could no longer not speak.
It is because I became empowered to write about my own adoption experience that I discovered other adoptees writing about theirs. I asked to join Lost Daughters and was amazed at being accepted, because I was no one.
And then I began a remarkable journey. Mostly online, I met adoptees from all over the world, some whose experience was very similar to mine, some whose experience was very different. Before interacting with other adoptees, I’d had no idea I wasn’t alone in the way adoption had affected my identity. I had assumed I was just broken.
I remember early on breaking down at the realization that an entire community of Korean adoptees existed. I had not been aware of that community and, to my knowledge, neither had my stepson. Why couldn’t I have known about this sooner? Would it have made a difference if he’d been able to connect with others like himself?
I wish I had been braver when I knew him. I wish I had been braver before I met him. I wish I’d had the courage to speak about my experience sooner, because maybe I would have discovered the community of adoptees sooner and maybe, if I’d been able to connect my stepson with them, it would have given him hope. Hope is what keeps us going.
I never set out to become an activist. I’m not comfortable now with that label. I’ve settled for the time being with explaining myself as an advocate.
When at last I felt empowered and I did set out, I wanted to write about my adoption experience so that others would be empowered to speak about theirs. These days, because of all that I’ve learned and continue to learn, I also want to write about overarching adoption issues, as well as other systemic issues, as well as additional personal challenges.
Maybe this is activism. Maybe it’s not. I don’t care how it’s perceived. I care about empowering others to speak. I care about offering hope.
6 thoughts on “Talking about Adoption in Public Spaces”
I don’t know if it’s activism at all, but I know that finally meeting and talking to other adoptees has utterly changed my life. I’m so sorry it wasn’t an option for your stepson.
It has changed my life, too. Thank you for reading and for leaving a note.
Reblogged this on ☀️ army of one ☀️ and commented:
Karen writes so beautifully
Wonderful post. I was adopted at birth too, and I reunited with my birth mother a few years ago. It’s been a bittersweet experience. Initially mindblowing and revelatory, a huge relief that my birth mom was willing to connect and then even meet, but at some point it became very difficult for me. She wanted me to call her mom, she wanted to exchange gifts for birthdays and holidays, she said “I love you” so easily, but it didn’t come easily or naturally at all to me. I couldn’t feel a connection just because she gave birth to me, perhaps because I didn’t grow up with her. She’s been hurt by my pulling away, but I just can’t fake it.
Thanks for reading and for leaving a note. I understand where you’re coming from. I’ve been in reunion for ten years now, and it hasn’t at all gone as I thought, or hoped, it would. In my case, I’m the one who seems to want too much. Despite the impasse I’m at now with my birth family, I’ve learned so much about myself I have no regrets. I’m a more whole person now. I don’t think you should ever fake feelings that you don’t have. There’s no such thing as an instant relationship, and our relationships with birth family members are like no other. There’s a connection, and yet there’s not. Hang in there!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Sorry, this is an old post and I’m only just seeing it now.
It’s funny you mention the activist thing. Someone described me as such and I wouldn’t have thought of it like that, but I suppose if you’re working for change then you could be rightly described as an activist. I think it involves being willing to approach hard topics head-on, without heed. And it sounds like you’re doing just that, using your personal experiences as your guide.
I love your blog!